Crumbs: Reviews » Comedies » How I Met Your Mother » Season 5 » Last Cigarette Ever
Critical reviews of U.S. TV shows
and analysis of what makes them
good, bad, irritating and enlightening.

How I Met Your Mother

How I Met Your Mother is a comedy about Ted Mosby, a New York architect who wants to get married and start a family. Future Ted is telling the story of how he met their mother and we see his past story set in the present day and the adventures he has with friends Marshall, Lily, Barney and Robin. CBS 2005-???


Episode 11 - Last Cigarette Ever

19 December 2009

Synopsis: Older Ted reveals to his children that the group used to smoke. Robin in particular was a consistent smoker. She is upset that her new co-host Don is deeply cynical and unprofessional. Marshall ends up smoking again as a way to bond with his new boss and his former boss, Arthur Hobbs. Lily, Ted and Barney all get sucked in and try to help each other quit for good.

The Good: It’s the same old story with How I Met Your Mother, though the plot was pretty solid in theory. The idea that older Ted hid the groups smoking habits from his children is plausible and an inoffensive way to add a new layer to their characters which was never there before. The end to that story where Ted lists when all of their last cigarettes were was a really nice touch. It gave the story a more significant feeling by linking it to future loves and babies. It keeps the story of the mother at the forefront of the show and gives some nice continuity plot points to be reached down the road.

Robin’s desire to be professional was an admirable idea. Bringing back Arthur (315) to provide Marshall with a good excuse to smoke was solid continuity. I even liked Arthur’s obsession with his dog, the one person in his life who doesn’t hate him.

The Bad: The only problem here is that all the attempts at humour are implausible exaggerations. These jokes wouldn’t happen in real life and so each time one appears it induces a groan rather than a laugh. And with any unreal exaggeration they run the risk of undermining the serious part of the story.

Don not wearing pants and smoking on the air are the worst offenders. One could get him fired and the other definitely would. The whole plot is built on the flawed logic that no one watches TV in the small hours of the morning. Many people would see them and to smoke on air would have the station being sued by everyone.

Ted and Barney reminisce about smoking in bars with a huge exaggeration of what that looked like. The gang go through typically exaggerated withdrawal symptoms when they try to give up smoking. Lily’s voice goes super deep from smoking so that a man does voiceovers for her, obviously not believable. And so on.

Comic Highlight: The only exaggeration which works is Marshall imagining kicking his thirteen year old self as he looks for someone to take out his withdrawal pain on.

How I rate your episode: A decent story with no good jokes.



Add your comments on this episode below. They may be included in the weekly podcasts.

Post your comment


  • Just reached this episode. Future Ted's kids are clearly high school aged, though very possibly even younger (especially in the son's case). Is that really the time you want to be telling them you used to smoke? Surely that gives a teenager all the rationale they need to give it a try themselves. "Well dad did it, so why shouldn't I try it? Who is he to tell me I can't?"

    Also Lily's voice is one of the more ridiculous gags the show has pulled in its run so far. Weak sauce.

    Posted by Brando, 27/05/2011 4:57am (8 years ago)

  • Hey Ryan, I recorded a podcast just for you :-) and hopefully other interested people. Thanks for the comments.

    Posted by The TV Critic, 29/09/2010 1:08am (9 years ago)

  • One point of contention. The joke isn't so much that nobody watches TV in the Early hours of the morning, it's that nobody watches that show in the early hours of the morning. So much so that the few people that would catch the show are either sleep deprived, or don't care about something like that.

    Not to mention it's a TV show that requires a small amount of suspension of disbelief. It is a sitcom after all with some things exaggerated. All of which are allowed for by Future Ted as an unreliable narrator. If something seems like it happened unnecessarily quickly, or wasn't 100% accurate, it most likely comes down to Ted either remembering wrong, or skipping ahead in the story. Once you start thinking this way, some of these... "oh that's not plausible" moments become not only easier to swallow, but part of the comedy as well. As far as the morning show goes, it might not be unreliable narration, but the world that these characters live in that allow them to get away with it. As with BBT you're content to let things that aren't plausible go for the sake of the joke, but for some reason you aren't able to here, which is surprising.

    Posted by Ryan Miller, 25/09/2010 2:21am (9 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments