Crumbs: Reviews » Comedies » The Big Bang Theory » Season 6 » The Spoiler Alert Segmentation
Critical reviews of U.S. TV shows
and analysis of what makes them
good, bad, irritating and enlightening.
55
/100
Viewer
62
/100

The Big Bang Theory

The Big Bang Theory is a comedy about two physicists Leonard Hofstadter and Sheldon Cooper who live and work together in Pasadena, California. They live a comfortable geeky existence until attractive wannabe actress Penny moves in across the hall. CBS 2007-???

42
/100
Viewer
40
/100

Episode 15 - The Spoiler Alert Segmentation

9 February 2013

Credit CBS

Synopsis: Sheldon spoils Leonard on the Harry Potter books and in anger Leonard announces he will be moving in with Penny. She is not thrilled and Sheldon is equally unhappy when Amy offers to move in. Meanwhile Howard asks Raj to look in on his mother while he is away and she won't let him leave.

The Good: The Amy-Sheldon part of this I could see. She desperately wants to move things forward and of course he isn't ready to have her living with him.

The Bad: However she was so distraught when he pulled away that it felt like a cop out when she merely heads to Penny's to complain. There's only so many times she can question how long she has to wait before she needs to pull the plug.

Obviously Leonard looked foolish and inconsiderate when he informed Penny that he would be moving in with her. But worse than that was his lack of excitement or emotion at that development. The focus shifted entirely to Penny's horror rather than stopping to think how much this commitment would actually mean to Leonard. She rightly fears that he will be hurt and the fact that they didn't discuss this big step at any point made it clear that the story was simply a gag and not a real event.

This plot also felt out of sync with Sheldon and Leonard's relationship. In the last year or so Leonard seemed to have become a little more assertive (only last episode he told him off) with Sheldon and so it felt odd to have him finally snap the way he did here. Again it felt like the writers following a template for comedy rather than thinking hard about the characters' state of mind.

I didn't mind the idea of Howard's mother trapping Raj but as always with The Big Bang Theory we just heard about it. The comedy was all meant to be from Raj on the phone telling Howard what was going on rather than actual jokes we could see. It was a forgettable C plot as a result.

In an episode which referenced spoiler alerts I thought the writers were a bit daring with The Walking Dead audience. They revealed a plot detail which only took place last Autumn and in an era when people often watch shows at their leisure that could have really spoilt a lot of people.

Comic Highlight: I couldn't find a comic highlight in this episode. If I worked hard I'm sure I could pick one that came closest to making me smile but it's a rarity for an episode to be this lacking in humour. The dialogue between Raj and Howard was especially poor and functional. Sheldon couldn't save it either, he received none of the colourful analogies that can usually be relied on.

In Conclusion: I thought this was a major disappointment. The character dynamics felt flippant in a way which ran counter to the gentle progress that's been made in the last couple of seasons.

Feedback

Add your comments on this episode below. They may be included in the weekly podcasts.

Post your comment

Comments

  • Re. funny things. I thought Raj's "oy vey" was pretty funny. A minor logical problem - Leonard apparently heard a spoiler from Penny about Harry Potter Book 5, but he mentioned in was on Book 6, and heard a spoiler from Sheldon about 6, so how is it possible that he could not have read 5? Seems like the writers were really not paying attention.

    Robin, re "felt odd to have him finally snap the way he did here", you mean you'd have expected him to be more assertive and calmer? I personally didn't find his reaction all that off. He must put up with a lot from Sheldon, and I guess it gets kinda bottled up. If one is rooming with a wacko it is probably not practical to complain constantly, so one gets into the habit of trying to ignore or overlook stuff, I suppose.

    Posted by Faheem, 09/02/2013 11:15am (6 years ago)

  • Not an especially funny episode.

    Humor usually redeems Sheldon’s egocentrism. We forgive his extreme self-centeredness because his quirkiness makes us laugh. But when the funny’s not there his self-satisfied close-mouthed smirk makes strangling Sheldon an option.

    Leonard’s forgiven nothing. He’s an inconsiderate fool for wanting to move in with Penny? Shame on him for thinking the forceful Penny would have said no if she wasn’t comfortable with the idea. Instead she uses Sheldon to reveal the truth. A break can not be had for the little fellow.

    Why do these people hang out with each other anymore? Their mutual interests and amusement used to explain a lot but I don’t see much of that anymore. I never much minded the characters’ shortcomings when they liked each other, but when they don’t…

    Viewer score: 40 / 100

    Posted by JStrange, 08/02/2013 9:42pm (6 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments