Crumbs: Reviews » Comedies » The Office
Critical reviews of U.S. TV shows
and analysis of what makes them
good, bad, irritating and enlightening.
53
/100
Viewer
49
/100

The Office

The Office is a comedy set in a paper sales company Dunder Mifflin. Shot in a mockumentary style the show follows the exploits of regional manager Michael Scott whose excruciating behaviour can make life difficult for his fellow employees. NBC 2005-???

Seasons

Season Overview #Episodes Score Viewer
score
Season 1 2005 6 57 -
Season 4 2007-08 14 54 -
Season 5 2008-09 26 62 -
Season 6 2009-10 24 57 -
Season 7 2010-11 24 53 84
Season 8 2011-12 24 43 35
Season 9 2012 23 45 48

Top episodes

Season
» Episode
Episode Overview Score Viewer score
Season 4
» Episode 8
The Deposition Michael is testifying at his deposition in Jan’s...
Michael is testifying at his deposition in Jan’s wrongful termination lawsuit. During cross examination the issue of when his relationship with Jan actually started comes up. The photo of them in Jamaica and his diary are both entered as exhibits. In the end he testifies in favour of the company. Back at the office there is a ping pong table in the warehouse. Jim has been losing to Darryl and Kelly talks smack to Pam about it. So Pam organises practise for Jim so that he can beat Darryl and defend her honour.
78 -
Season 5
» Episode 1
Weight Loss We see Dunder Mifflin’s summer. Corporate offer a...
We see Dunder Mifflin’s summer. Corporate offer a prize to the office that can lose the most weight and of course Michael takes it very seriously. Angela is still sleeping with Dwight while Andy plans their wedding. Pam is in New York on a design course and Jim ends up proposing to her. Ryan returns as a temp to replace Pam. Michael is still being friends with Holly even though he wants to ask her out. A forty minute long single episode.
75 -
Season 5
» Episode 4
Crime Aid Michael and Holly go on their third date...
Michael and Holly go on their third date and forget to lock the office. It gets robbed and Michael arranges “Crime Aid” to try and raise money to replace people’s personal items. He draws a crowd by pretending to have Bruce Springsteen tickets. Dwight asks Phyllis for help with how to win Angela back. Jim meets Roy at the bar. David Wallace arrives and discovers that Michael and Holly are dating.
73 -
Season 5
» Episode 26
Company Picnic It’s the Dunder Mifflin company picnic. Michael heads...
It’s the Dunder Mifflin company picnic. Michael heads off with Holly to work on their sketch about the history of the company with a plan to tell her why she should get back together with him. Dwight rallies the Scranton branch to play well in the inter-branch volleyball match. He is aided by Jim and particularly Pam who it turns out has played a lot. Michael and Holly’s sketch Slumdunder Mifflinaire is a disaster including the revelation that the Buffalo branch is going to close. Pam injures her ankle in the final match between the New York branch and Scranton. Jim rushes her to the hospital while Dwight tries to stall things. At the hospital they discover that Pam is pregnant.
73 -
Season 6
» Episode 4
Niagara It’s Jim and Pam’s wedding in Niagra Falls....
It’s Jim and Pam’s wedding in Niagra Falls. Michael is hugely excited for all sorts of reasons including the pickup opportunities. He is frustrated to find he can’t get a room and Dwight steals the girl he was after. He seeks comfort in the arms of the similarly bitter Mrs Beasley. Andy tears his scrotum and Kevin’s shoes get thrown away. On the day of the wedding Jim whisks Pam away to get married on a cruise ship. They return to complete the formal ceremony only for their friends to act out a popular youtube wedding video.
73 -

Credit NBC

NOW SHOWING

USA: NBC
UK: Comedy Central

ORIGINS

The Office was originally a British series written by Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant. The US version was adapted by Greg Daniels. Daniels, an experienced writer for SNL and The Simpsons researched office life before working on the series. He also decided to make the pilot a direct adaption from the first British episode. From then on the show got its own scripts and began to diverge considerably from the original. The show is unusual in casting a group of actors known for their improv skills along with several members of the writing staff.

CONTENT

The show debuted after The Apprentice on a Thursday (in April 2005) but was then moved to Tuesdays where half the original audience didn't follow. However buzz about the show was strong and Steve Carell's profile was raised through his role in The 40 Year Old Virgin. The show returned with around eight million viewers and was eventually promoted to NBC's Thursday's where it has remained the highest rated show of that block.

While I recognised the genius behind Ricky Gervais' creation I wasn't a big fan of the British Office. I found it to be cold and focussing on human embarrassment and misery in a way which turned me off. That emotion continued to be exploited in the American version but Steve Carell turned out to be an inspired piece of casting. The writing followed his childish enthusiasm for his work and by season four Michael had actually become something of a beloved figure.

During seasons two and three the fledgling romance between Jim and Pam carried much of the emotion on the show. However by seasons four and five Michael's stories had come to dominate and generate much sympathy for him. The show's quality began to dip in season six and worrying signs grew throughout season seven. However the writers gave Michael a memorable season-worth of closure as they prepared for Steve Carell's departure in May 2011.

By now Greg Daniels had moved on to Parks and Recreation and Paul Lieberstein (Toby from the show) was in charge. He made the decision to promote Andy Bernard into Michael's role both within the show (he became manager) and structurally (the focus on the office manager remained the same).

THETVCRITIC

As I said above I didn't warm to the dark direction The Office seemed to be taking comedy. I did recognise though the addictive quality of seeing comedy presented as real life rather than having actors performing for a live audience. To some extent the show got around this limitation by writing Michael as a man who thought work was meant to be fun and he was a master entertainer.

As time went on The Office slowly became far more like a traditional sit com and became funnier as a result. Seasons four and five produced some fantastic comic television and genuinely turned Michael into one of the best comedy characters around. The slow decline from there was sad to see and after Michael left the show there was no change in direction. For now the show seems set to continue for some time as NBC's struggles to find success continue.

LEGACY

While not quite a spin off Parks and Recreation (2009) was shot in the exact same style as The Office and mimicked many of the successful qualities of its parent show. Then came ABC's Modern Family (2009), a huge mainstream hit comedy which also aped the mockumentary format without any actual explanation for why cameras would be following the characters around. This was undoubtedly influenced by the success of The Office where the cameras presence increasingly just became a fact of the shows life which went uncommented upon.

The success of a show based around an unlikeable or abrasive character was influential as was the focus on scene intended to make the audience uncomfortable. While not originating with The Office these ideas were given greater exposure and came to have an effect on future commissioning of comedy shows.

December 2011